Off the Back of a Lorry in a Shady Car-Park…
Ms Raccoon has been out and about – taking her business to the fat man who works out of the back of a lorry in a secret location. When I say ‘fat’ I am talking a human being of Cyril Smith dimensions – they say it is the poor and underprivileged who reach these dimensions, they can’t afford better quality food, and don’t have sufficient education to know how to eat sensibly. Hmmn.
I arrived, clutching the map that had been sent to me, with an ‘x’ marking the exact spot where I would find him – that day, that hour, only – it was in one of those concrete loading bays that frequently feature in cops and robber dramas. A hearse pulled up next to it. The lorry was closed up, no sign of life, but a hand written sign invited me to pick up a nearby telephone and call Fatman’s mobile. He answered straight away – ‘Name?’ – I gave him my name. ‘OK, I’ll send someone to get you, wait there’.
55 minutes later, someone did in fact arrive to collect me, and I entered the Lorry.
In search of cheap cigarettes? Cut price Booze? What nefarious business did you imagine Ms Raccoon was conducting?
None of the above – I was entering the world of our ‘world class NHS’ – you know, that leviathan of the public sector that the Tory’s are allegedly going to ‘privatise’, something we are assured will bring about a disastrous lowering of the immaculate NHS standards. Ms Raccoon was about to enjoy ‘cutting edge’ medical technology with diagnostic imaging…yes, my three monthly PET scan was due again.
Now the ‘somebody’ who arrived to collect me is a lovely girl, same one as last time, full of good humour and cheer; about my height, and slender – she needs to be. There is not much room for her – she lives in a cubicle at the back of the lorry which, I kid you not, is smaller than the average toilet cubicle. This is the second time in my life that I have found myself playing ‘footsie’, nay ‘kneesie’ as well, with a woman. Same woman as well.
‘We’ll have to stop meeting like this’, I quipped. She giggled. I wriggled. Out of my coat. It’s cold in that tha’r car park, but now she needed me half naked. She stuck a needle in my arm. Well done her! I’ve only got one vein left that will oblige and she hit it first time. ‘You know the routine now, I’ll give you my keys’, she said. ‘Keys?’ ‘Mmmn, keys to the staff toilet in the main building’. I felt positively privileged as I climbed back down from the back of the lorry, across the car park, and glancing furtively from left to right, entered the main building.
Down one of the endless corridors – count..one..two..three crisp and chocolate vending machines, turn right, past a vast restaurant filled with munching humans, and there was the staff toilet! I took off my clothes, put on the paper nightgown and threw my coat back on – and then I took a wrong turning.
This time I found myself passing the light and spacious ‘Muslim prayer room’, next to the chapel. Then a curious space in the centre of the thoroughfare, backing onto another huge restaurant full of chattering munchers. The tiny space was bordered on three sides by those temporary panels they use in exhibitions. No roof, half of one side left open to allow entry, and precisely the width of a small sofa. Inside you could see just such an item – a small sofa – and perhaps three foot of floor space in front of it. Nothing else. Just a sign affixed to the wall that read ‘Please respect the privacy of bereaved relatives using this space’.
50% of human beings die in a hospital, not many go there in search of the gourmet diet – so it seems a curious division of space that so little is given up for the needs of their bereaved relatives – and so much squandered on selling food?
Still, back to the car park. The expensive car park. £2.50 an hour actually. 4 hours I was there. Free at the point of delivery, eh? I shivered and tapped on the door of the lorry again, and Ms Chirpy let me in, I don’t know how she stays so cheerful.
This time I passed through a narrow doorway into a corridor. A remarkably grubby corridor; not that I am Mrs Houseproud, but the hour I passed sitting in that narrow corridor could have usefully been spent with a scrubbing brush and a bottle of Flash. There is no window, nothing to look at bar count the fingerprint marks and wonder at the scuffles that have taken place and resulted in stains on the ceiling for God’s sake! Perhaps I’ll take some Flash with me next time.
Fatman appeared, shirt hanging out of his crumpled jeans, and connected a metal tube to the needle in my arm, and pressed the trigger to put the radioactive liquid into me. ‘You’ve got to ‘cook’ for an hour now’, he said, and squeezed his bulk through the admittedly tiny door. A low moaning from behind me told me that I had company. An elderly man, in a chair facing the other way, also apparently ‘cooking’. Radioactive companions, we were, glowing in togetherness. He didn’t sound as though he was enjoying it much. Nobody came to see why.
An interminable hour later, the door swung open again, and Fatman re-appeared, beckoning me into his inner sanctum. The beating heart of this ‘white hot’ technology. It might have been white twenty years ago – now it was, like the corridor, grubby and stained. ‘Could I have a blanket?’ I whimpered. ‘I’m frozen’. He produced a length of tin foil, those emergency wraps they use on marathon runners. ‘Lie down, breath normally, keep absolutely still’, he grunted. That was the extent of our conversation. I read the label on his chest. ‘Senior technician’ it said. Not poor or uneducated then.
15 minutes later, I’d had my scan. I’ll get the results on the 14th April. Yes, that is a month away, but what’s a brief four weeks to wonder what Fatman knows about my body that I don’t? It’ll soon pass. He is qualified to make me radioactive, but not to speak to me. That requires another expert. She’s on leave. She was last time I had a scan. I had to wait a month then.
I have been spoilt in France. When they saying cutting edge technology, they mean it. Everything happens with the speed of light, everything is sanitised and spotless. The PET scan takes place in a suite of purpose built rooms in the bowls of the building, conducted by healthy looking staff in crisp white protective clothing. But then that is a ‘privatised service’, you have a choice where to go. When they say ‘free at the point of delivery’, which it is for any French resident with a life threatening condition, they mean it. They give you the result straight away (admittedly for a PET scan that does mean a couple of days later, it is more complicated than the ordinary CT scan to develop the pictures).
So would the NHS be improved by ‘privatisation’? Well, there’s the rub. You see what I was ‘enjoying’ was privatisation. The British version. Actually, not just the British version, but the Labour British version.
‘Inhealth’ which owns this flipping lorry, was set up under a Labour government in 2004.
InHealth provides diagnostics and imaging services to the NHS and private hospitals and clinics, including MRI, CT, X-Ray, DXA, Nuclear Medicine, Mammography, Ultrasound, Interventional Cardiology, Audiology, ENT, Endoscopy and Physiological Measurement. The company employs about 1000 people, including clinical specialists and patient referral teams. Its services are provided from over 280 locations in the UK and Ireland and they work with a significant majority of NHS Trusts in the UK covering over 200 hospitals and over 80 community health clinics. The company saw over 500,000 patients in 2011. InHealth is a Choose and Book provider, fully integrated with the NHS Image Exchange Portal (IEP).
Ivan Bradbury, who ‘is’ Inhealth by the yardstick of the man in the street, used to run an electronics business. He sold it well and thus had substantial funds. In 1998 He ‘was advised’ to invest those funds in British healthcare, circuitously into a company now known as Inhealth, via a holding company in Luxembourg.
Entirely coincidentally, in the same year, Tony Blair and Gordon Brown took the reins of government, and started a programme of privatising the NHS. Good fortune smiles on those in the right place at the right time.
(For his subsequent problems viz a viz the advice given by his accountants as to the most tax efficient nay, nay, not tax evasive, way of structuring this see his subsequent legal action against his accountants.)
In their book The Plot against the NHS, Colin Leys and Stewart Player argue that, having failed to persuade the public and the medical establishment under Margaret Thatcher that the NHS should be turned into a European-style national insurance programme, the advocates of a competitive health market gave up trying to convince the big audience and focused on infiltrating Whitehall’s policymaking centres and the think tanks.
Entirely coincidentally, Ivan Bradbury became chairman of the Trustees of Civitas, just such a think tank, which produces such publications as “A return to the NHS’s core values” which – oh go on then, you’re ahead of me, aren’t you? – turns out to be an entreaty to fund the NHS by giving patients a budget which they could choose where to spend…
“Enhanced choice will ensure that people who are left unhappy with health services in their area will have a wide variety of options at their disposal, not simply voting for a new government in the hope that healthcare reforms could take place. Importantly, this will enfranchise those for whom completely ‘private’ healthcare would never be affordable.”
Now I don’t begrudge Ivan Bradbury his Dragon class yacht, nor the time in which to race it, not at all, at all – he has built a successful business. What is puzzling me is a) How come the British version of privatisation turns out to be a grubby lorry in a parking bay, not the sleek French version, and b) why are we hearing so much from the Labour party about the ‘NHS being safe in their hands – unlike the nasty Tories’, when it turns out the Tories rejected privatisation plans, which promptly then prospered under 13 years of Labour rule, and c) why has this hospital got four different restaurants, a clothes shop (I kid you not), its own branch of WH Smiths, its own Costa coffee shop, a bloody expensive car park, and yet has neither space nor funds to carry out its core functions, which is surely diagnosing disease, treating it, and dealing compassionately with the relatives of those it has failed?
The NHS is putting me in mind of the Vatican – a self governing state within a state, that cannot be policed, criticised, or modernised – but is incredibly good at raking in funds and handing them out to the chosen few.
- GildasTheMonk
March 22, 2015 at 9:04 am -
Brilliant, Boss. On a wider point, or a variation of the theme, one of the reasons politicians are in such disrepute is the total disconnection between what politicians tell us is happening with their faux stats and soundbites, and the reality of actual experience. But as long as the numbers sound good, who cares?
- Mudplugger
March 22, 2015 at 9:15 am -
The NHS is rather like ‘Immigration’ – saying anything critical has long been a taboo, even though that critique could be positive and helpful.
Fortunately, and entirely due to ballot-fear of UKIP, the I-word has now become an acceptable topic for some limited discussion: the NHS only remains open for debate with regard to how much more cash to throw at it whilst never demanding any improvement, regardless of which party currently holds the purse-strings for this most sacred of electoral cows.
‘Envy of the world’, apparently. - Tom O’Carroll
March 22, 2015 at 10:17 am -
“Labour will make us as bad as France”, says David Cameron writing in an article he has written for today’s Sunday Times: http://www.thesundaytimes.co.uk/sto/news/uk_news/article1534611.ece
Now I’m really confused. Shouldn’t that be as good as France? But why would Cameron think Labour would be so successful, especially in view of what Anna says about their awful privatisation legacy? And why would he support his political opponents anyway? My head is spinning!
Things might make sense if I could read beyond the headline, but the article itself is hidden behind Mr Murdoch’s paywall.
- The Blocked Dwarf
March 22, 2015 at 11:48 am -
” My head is spinning!”
that’ll be from the Pile Cream that nice young Asian doctor prescribed you by mistake because your Urdu isn’t up to scratch. Don’t worry, NICE have said it is ok for use despite being only a 3rd of the cost of ‘real’ medication and do try not to worry about the rumours it contains polonium234whatever. …you’ll die long before the effected area starts glowing in the dark.
- The Blocked Dwarf
- The Blocked Dwarf
March 22, 2015 at 10:46 am -
“In search of cheap cigarettes? Cut price Booze? What nefarious business did you imagine Ms Raccoon was conducting?”
Reminds of my days of being an “Ambot”, exchanging kilo bags of crystalline white powder out of car boots in some dark car park late at night “Truthfully Officer, it is ‘Magic’ powder, the power of concentrated SA8 compels”. (‘Ambot’= Amway seller, ‘SA8’ = washing powder, for the none Ex-Amwayers among us).
Anyways being a dwarf means having neck problems -all that looking up! (mind you I did used to say that ‘if you can hear the soppy music she put on then you’re doing it wrong!’ -ponder that one a mo’). In January my GP booked me in for an MRI scan. The scan took place last week. As it was a non-emergency, I really don’t think that some alien spawn is going to erupt from the back of my neck Weaveresque style, I was fine with having to wait 2 months.
I was given an evening appointment at our local Was-A-Town-Hospital-But-Now-Glorified-OAP Day Care Center in the brand new MRI unit, a shed in the car park, but a tastefully painted shed and there was on the road parking nearby so I didn’t have to sell off my first granddaughter to pay for parking. I turned up a bit early and has forced to spend 3/4 of an hour listening to Radio Rabbit Breeder Tea Time Show but my appointment was for 19:15 and 19:10 on the dot they called me in. Quick, friendly and professional -the Receptionist and Technicians both….although the cleaner less so.
I suppose the only difference I could find to having such a scan abroad, somewhere where they ENVY the NHS, charge you a fortune before they’ll even treat you and the doctors give you tablets up your bum (the 3 prevailing myths about ‘foreign’ European health care of my childhood) was the initial wait time to get the scan. Pretty sure if I had seen my German GP he’d have gotten me ‘in’ within a fortnight and I wouldn’t have had to change in the broom cupboard.
- English Pensioner
March 22, 2015 at 12:28 pm -
My wife need a scan on her spine, she has osteoporosis and our GP said she’d arrange an appointment. Well, my wife had to wait about 3 months for the previous one so had put it out of her mind.
The following morning, the phone rand “This is the NHS diagnostic centre,when would you like to come in for your scan?” Somewhat taken by surprise, and never having heard of any diagnostic centre, my wife suggested as soon as possible. “Would 10.00 tomorrow morning suit?”. This was agreed and my wife was told where the centre was (as we’d never heard of it), “Come five minutes or so before, so you can fill in the forms”.
Next morning we ventured off to this new place and wondered where we were going. It was housed in a unit in a local light industrial estate, there was free parking and we arrived a few minutes early as suggested. Quite a nice reception area a few chairs and just one other person waiting. A very smart receptionist took the details and spot on ten o’clock, before my wife had had a chance to try out their chairs she was called for the scan. I waited, they were very comfortable chairs and there were a couple of the day’s newspapers to read. A quarter of a hour later, all was done and my wife was told the results would be with the GP in a couple of days.
This was free at the point of use. It was run by a private company under contract. If this is privatisation, I’m all for it. If the company makes a profit and it costs the NHS no more than it would in-house, good luck to them. - Kevin B
March 22, 2015 at 1:04 pm -
The restaurants, flower shops, fruit sellers and charity shops that take up a lot of space in the big NHS hospitals these days are, of course, annoying but at least they contribute to the cost of running the place.
Far more insidious are the offices, and indeed office blocks, of the administrators who are, for the most part, a drain on the NHS and on patient care but who seem to proliferate with every new reorganisation that the politicians come up with.
This may be why your PET scan was carried out in a truck in the car park. The local, county, regional and national administrators have taken most of the budget for themselves and their pensions.
- binao
March 22, 2015 at 1:24 pm -
A bad experience.
My late wife (and me as her minder) became fed up with the grime, interminable but unexplained waiting even to collect medication, & offhand sometimes rude staff, not all but too many. I think I referred to the National Death Service.
However,
I’ve made the point before that over the past two years I’ve seen a lot of my nearest South Coast hospital (not the same hospital as above), both as a patient & acting as minder to a good friend. About 4 years ago I wasn’t at all impressed. There was then the feel of a business close to collapse, very rough at the edges.
I’ve been in for treatment in two different departments, and last November was blue lighted in to A & E, then to AMU.
All of those experiences have been good. I’m better, & still in the system.
Modern & spotless, gone are the tumbleweed balls of fluff bowling down the corridors; kindly & concerned staff. I mentioned this to a doctor there & she agreed, there had been real change. I made my last appointments while there, no waiting for letters to be sent, and I know that if I’m early, there’s a good chance of being seen early, no waiting around.
So it can be done.
Car park’s still expensive & often full, though I have on occasion gone in for a blood test & out again within the 20 minute discretionary period, so no charge.
Again, it can be done. - Sir Henry Rawlinson
March 22, 2015 at 1:57 pm -
A tale of our times Ms Raccoon. Inhealth have performed two colonoscopy on me in recent times in a converted office suite above a Chinese takeaway. The first, the last appointment of the day, was rushed and the staff were desperate to go home. The second, the first appointment of the day, was much better. On neither occasion was information passed to my GP in a timely manner. Prescription quantities are still a matter of guesswork with neither Inhealth, GP nor Hospital being certain about how to treat me. This is only for colitis. I admire your courage and fortitude in dealing with so much more serious illness.
- Ancient+Tattered Airman
March 22, 2015 at 1:59 pm -
All power to your radioactive arm Ma’am (And naturally to the rest of you too!)
- Mudplugger
March 22, 2015 at 4:59 pm -
One excellent example of NHS competence is this weekend’s issue of the vaccine for Maningitis B. It seems that the NHS had announced they were going to start vaccinating all kids – and only then started to negotiate the price with the sole-supplier of the vaccine.
I’ve done a fair bit of chunky corporate purchasing in my time at national level and the one thing you don’t do, as a buyer, is let the supplier know that you’re already publicly committed to their product before settling on the price deal. Otherwise, they’ve got you by the nuts, which is exactly where Jeremy Rhyming-Slang is at the moment. I’m sure the NHS has got offices full of ‘procurement professionals’ with glossy certificates splattered over all their office-walls, but none of them know the first thing about real buying in the real world from smart suppliers. Keep the supplier more desperate to sell you seem to be to buy and the right price will follow, as night follows day.
- The Blocked Dwarf
March 22, 2015 at 6:15 pm -
“and only then started to negotiate the price with the sole-supplier of the vaccine”
That’ll keep the Swiss in fondue and raclette for a bit. What a Freund/Ami/Amico they have in the NHS. Big Pharma UK being too busy funding Antismoker lobby groups.
- The Blocked Dwarf
- Lilith
March 22, 2015 at 6:19 pm -
I was offered a mammogram 35 miles away in a city I’m unfamiliar with. I thought I’ll take my chances and declined. Later, during a routine local appointment with a nurse she asked if I’d been offered one. When I explained her jaw dropped and she exclaimed “But the mobile unit is just outside this building!”. Turns out I could have had my tits squashed and irradiated locally.
- Alex
March 22, 2015 at 8:44 pm -
Well, I personally haven’t met anbody with anything good to say about our “wonderful” NHS. Indeed one family friend refers to it as the “No Hope Service”.
My mother now resides in a private nursing home, a rather nice place where she is looked after quite well. One night in February I got a phone call to say that it was thought she might have suffered a stroke and was being taken to the local A&E in Worcester. I said I would make my way to the hospital. What a nightmare exerience that turned out to be. She arrived there at about 10.30 pm. She remained on the ambulance stretcher bed and was placed in the queu along the very lengthy corridor and was slowly moved along as the patients at the front were dealt with. There were only 2 doctors on duty and it took until 4.30 am before she was seen to. The main Hospital is often closed to visitors due to outbreaks of Noro Virus. I, my father and my brother all caught Noro in 2010 after visiting my mother who was then being treated for an alleged clot on the brain thought to be responsible for her symptoms, which was diagnosed later that year as Parkinsons. This Hospital was opened in 2002.
To put it bluntly, the place is a fucking disgrace. It was intentionally planed with minimal car parking. Not long after it opened the post was advertised for a person with “logistics skills”, complete with a £30,000 salary, to advise staff on alternative ways to get to work. The approach road to the main entrance feels like the way to the service area where the bins are kept. This was a “green field site”. It is all hilly and undulating. It could, and should, have been levelled, but oh no the architects and planners knew better. So now sick and ill people have to walk up and down steep pathways. Some of the departments are physically separated from the main building so patients have to wait until an ambulance can ferry them from unit to unit. Apparently, staff are not allowed to move patients around the site in wheelchairs. The entrance area is a vast “atrium” and there is no reception desk at all. They rely on “volunteers” to give advice to patients and visitors. I could go on, but I won’t.
All this contrasts completely with what my friends who live in France tell me about the French health system. Their experience is identical to Anna’s. - Henry the Horse
March 22, 2015 at 10:24 pm -
Good points but hard to workout where it all leads. It sound to me that Anna has turned socialist and wants a French system (I wonder how much it is subsidised by their higher tax rates?) in the UK. Certainly she is against ‘stealth privisation’ and I agree with her on that but it is not just Blair and Labout who are responsible for this. The coalition has introduced even more ‘competition’ in the NHS which has brought it to the brink of privatisation through contracting.
I live in a European state, somewhat similar to France, that spends 13% of GDP on healthcare compared to the UK’s 8%. Perhaps Anna’s experience with cancer treatment only suggests cancer treatment there is better organised in France. Personally when I was last living in the UK and complaing of a sore knee I was amazed at the speed with which I was sent for a CAT scan and indeed even slightly worried that I didn’t have to wait more than a few weeks. Where I am now I have waited four hours in a room of fifteen square metres that smelled strongly of sick and had no windows for my daughter’s infected eye to be seen to. I had had my son have a milk tooth that was about to fall pulled for no more reaons than the dentist fancied the fee.
It is all well and good for Anna to say how great France is but the only option on offer in the UK at the moment is ever more in the direction of the USA and she even says as much in the post. The people who are pushing are the lobbyists of big healthcare corporations. I don’t think they have anyone’s interests at heart but their bottom line. The US healthcare system (words too grand for it) is a mess that cost three times as much as the UK for vastly poorer results. Surely nobody wants that?
My aunt was a keen Conseravtive. Her husband had even stood for the party once and was for many years a councillor. She had her BUPA insurance so that she never needed to mix on the wards. But when the time came and she had a hip that needed to be replaced her private providers fucked it up leaving her in considerable pain and making her final years a lot less pleasant than they might have been. A doctor friend told me that what you should look for above all when going for an operation is a doctor who does nothing else but what you are in for. He is much less likely to be able to deal with a difficult case than a doctor who will turn his hand to any operation that the patrons who are in the private system for better accomdoation and food require. Private is great in the UK at the moment if you choose a hospital on the same basis as a hotel. But if you want the best go for the factory approach.
- Moor Larkin
March 23, 2015 at 10:31 am -
Looking at Florida, they are known to have an aged population. The population is 20 million, which is ~30% of the UK number.
UK State spend on the NHS is £113B I understand, so 30% of that is £34B.
Florida’s State spend is 34B….. but dollars….
http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/spending_chart_2003_2020FLb_16c1li211mcn_10c
Do the math, as they say over there.
- Moor Larkin
- tom
March 23, 2015 at 12:07 am -
I look at the (no so recent) state of the art MRI scanner at my nearest NHS “depot”, noted the £5 million price tag and the fact that it seems to operate 9-5 weekdays (except for some emergencies) and wondered at a 80 year old pal of my dad who was advised of a six month waiting list for a scan – but nudge, nudge we can arrange a private one for you next week. At one stage the senior managers seemingly preferred venue for dealing with contractors was a local golf course.
The NHS is putting me in mind of the Vatican – a self governing state within a state, that cannot be policed, criticised, or modernised – but is incredibly good at raking in funds and handing them out to the chosen few.
Public OR Private – the management are taking the piss. Presently there are precious few consequences for this – in other (public sector) places inadequacy, incompetence and oftentimes far worse are handsomely rewarded with payoffs and platinum pensions.
Railing about it is a temporary relief – short of a cull – what is to be done ?
- binao
March 23, 2015 at 7:49 am -
I’ve made my comments above about the transformed quality of care I’ve had locally over the past 2 years, admittedly restricted to cardiac, lots of treatment, colorectal, 3 times & seen within days, & A & E/AMU. All very well run.
I’ve seen the great quality of care in France too when my terminally ill sister lived in H.Vienne a few years ago.
It’s obvious that most people on here aren’t getting this standard of care.
My view is that as in most organisations, it’s mostly about the people, not the structures, pay etc. It’s perhaps an indication of the mind set of politicians & senior civil servants that improvements are to be got either by tipping in buckets of money, or by turning the whole thing upside down. But then they’re not likely to be users, are they?
I certainly think there are NHS activities that are better done privately; I’m sure all those cardboard bottles & pans, & syringes aren’t made in-house, for a start. It’s also useful to be able contract care to meet capacity needs, why wouldn’t you? I think too that the bit that has always been private, our GPs, needs sorting. Why on earth are we travelling 10-15 miles to a hospital for minor or routine stuff that could be done round the corner?
Finally, I’ve seen somewhere that the nhs has around 1,5 million employees. There are about 30 million in work in this country, so when you walk down the road you’re bound to meet some of them…
Then there’s the private health sector, contractors etc… - Lysistrata Eleftheria
March 23, 2015 at 8:02 am -
I write, as I’ve mentioned before, as someone with incurable cancer, so first, Anna, I hope whatever treatment and tests they’re giving you at this stage are as least arduous as possible.
As a result of my cancer , I’ve spent over a year experiencing in depth the English NHS. Although it’s only anecdotal, the quality and amount of care I’ve had locally has been state-of-the-art, timely, and compassionate. As a simple example, our scanning services operate appointments at weekends as well as weekdays. (They also have a rather fine set of waiting room magazines including ‘Current Archaeology’.)
My heart goes out to those who’ve not received such good service.
Venality undoubtedly exists in the NHS, as it does throughout the public sector and particularly at the interface with the private sector where the greatest opportunity to benefit personally seems to lie. We have only to glance back at the T. Dan Smith and Poulson era of planning scandals, or the most recent news about our MPs selling access to policy makers.
There have always been people without honour. Our task is constant: to hold them to account.- IlovetheBBC
March 25, 2015 at 12:28 am -
Glad to hear of your good experience Lysistrsta – I think the truth is the NHS really is a Postcode Lottery. And a Curate’s Egg. When it’s good, and it is good in parts, it’s bloody wonderful. And when it’s bad it’s soul-destroyingly awful.
What’s happened over the last couple of decades is that the gap between the two extremes has widened. Did the rot begin with the setting up of the ‘Trusts’?
- IlovetheBBC
- Moor Larkin
March 23, 2015 at 8:12 am -
They fuck you up, your National Health.
They may not mean to, but they do.
They fill you with the faults they had
And add some extra, just for you.But they were fucked up in their turn
By fools in old-style hats and coats,
Who half the time were soppy-stern
And half at one another’s throats.Man hands on misery to man.
It deepens like a coastal shelf.
Get out as early as you can,
And don’t get ill yourself.- Mudplugger
March 23, 2015 at 10:27 am -
Larkin would be proud.
- Mudplugger
- steve lewis
March 23, 2015 at 8:15 am -
Truth is – it isn’t political. It’s driven by avarice, a desire to extract every single pound of currency. It is not relevant who is in power, they have the same agenda. You can see this in the way the “opposing” parties banter, it is merely part of the game.
- Ms Mildred
March 23, 2015 at 9:32 am -
No doubt it is a worrying time when ones health hits the buffers. I have a feeling that those of us who have to use the service, due to age, are made very wary and worried by constant carping about standards, the amount being leeched off for compensation too. There is no perfection in anything in life….sighs. It stands to reason that any oldie who is relatively socially isolated and goes into hospital stands a good chance of getting an infection of some sort. People with dementia can get very aggressive when being asked to eat….so they get terribly thin. As a student nurse I was detailed to help such a lady with soup from a feeder cup. She saved up a mouthful and expertly blew it all over me. My close friend was the same at the end. She just faded away. The NHS is expected to do gastric banding on self afflicted gross obesity. Treat drunks who have been fighting. Treat mass footy and rugger injuries at the weekend. Do amazing heart surgery on tiny newborns. All the time hassled by greedy lawyers bleeding money from the NHS. There is nothing new about privatised routine surgery for, say hernias. It was done during Blair’s time as PM.
- Gloria Smudd
March 23, 2015 at 10:44 am -
I have spent quite a bit of time in smart, shiny, efficiently-run Oncology departments accompanying family members to hospital for their diagnosis/treatment. I have also spent a great deal of time sitting by a bed in run down, poorly-managed Geriatric Medicine departments and, from my experience, the two sections of the NHS may as well be on different planets.
- Lysistrata Eleftheria
March 23, 2015 at 4:14 pm -
@Gloria – indeed.
In fact, it’s touch and go whether geriatric or mental health services are the worst in the NHS. It would be interesting to compare with other countries’ – I suspect the same might hold true.
I’m also embarrassed by the ease and speed with which I can obtain pain relieving drugs that work, while knowing people who are in chronic and far worse pain than me who have been offered Cognitive Behaviour Therapy or Mindfulness training instead, FFS.
Oh, and while I have readers’ attention, if I haven’t yet laid my stall out properly, let me state here I am firmly anti-woo. Coffee ground enemas, ground apricot kernels, manuka honey and a paleo diet have as much effect on cancer as Hopi ear candles.
- The Blocked Dwarf
March 23, 2015 at 6:25 pm -
” It would be interesting to compare with other countries’ – I suspect the same might hold true.”
It certainly was the case in Germany throughout the 80s and 90s to my knowledge. I only hope things have improved over there because German Secure Wards were bad to the point of inducing suicidal depression in me, heaven alone knows what they did to The Bestes Paranoidest Psychotic Frau In The World. I actually had to break her out under threat of copious, colorful and gratuitous violence towards the ‘doctor’ and armed guards- oops i mean ‘nurses’ , mind you that was back in the unenlightened, patriarchal days when a husband could secure his wife’s release legally, simply by uttering the archaic phrase “she leaves with me NOW or your internal organs do’ or some other ancient legalistic formula…
- Gloria Smudd
March 23, 2015 at 8:13 pm -
@Lysistrata Eleftheria: your comment about the pain management issue struck a chord with me; I believe that there are two types of opening statements during a patient consultation which the GP will welcome and one is the “I’ve found a lump” and the other is “I’ve got backache”. The first statement will have the consultation over in the allotted 10 minutes because the GP will click onto his/her standard cancer referral letter and send your complaint off to the local Oncology department and from then on you are out of his/her hair and will be seen promptly by the best-run part of the NHS … the second statement will also have the consultation over in the allotted 10 minutes but what you will get is an appointment with the Practice physio who will give you some simplified yoga exercises to do for a month and you might be lucky enough to get a prescription for a short course of Diclofenac and half a Diazepam to calm you while you live with the pain. I have been through both ‘pathways’ and I know which one fails the patient.
- The Blocked Dwarf
- Lysistrata Eleftheria
- gareth
March 24, 2015 at 10:43 am -
Good article and good too that you seem a chipper raccooness
I posted a link to this on Tim Worstall’s blog as one of his interests is NHS compared with other systems/countries.
{ 39 comments… read them below or add one }