Dove Tales.
When we lived in the ancienne poste house in the centre of the village, built into the metre thick walls of the bastide, one of the delights was sitting on the terrace in the morning sun listening to the doves cooing. They are a flock of white doves that have lived in the various dovecotes dotted around the village since medieval times. Although they are vegetarian – they do eat Termites, the bane of much of southern France. This village is proud of its reputation for being termite free, and local folklore attributes this to our Doves. They are jealously guarded. It was old Alice who told me that they were descended from an albino pigeon in Mesopotamia which was worshipped for its fecundity and fidelity – I thought she was joking, but lo! she was right as usual…
Then we moved to the old Mill, just 100 yards away, and no more did we hear the sound of the doves; until last year. A couple of devotees of ‘Escape to the Country’ had decided that this year they would bring up their youngsters in the wild country outside the bastide – they took up residence in the Cotinus tree, in the shade of the vermillion leaves. I couldn’t do much physically last year, and dove watching made a pleasant alternative to ‘outrage’ watching on the Internet. Peace and War, interspersed.
From sunrise to sunset, Mr and Mrs Dove would fly in and out of that tree, 20, 30 times an hour; we assumed they were building an elaborate nest, but as the cerise flowers fell away we realised that not only had they built into the cruck of a near leafless and feeble branch, their hard work amounted to little more than a raft of twigs. In the summer storms, when I had to watch from indoors, Mrs Dove could clearly be seen swaying dangerously, her ample bulk overflowing the nest which seemed barely big enough to contain her feet.
She had laid an egg though; at sunset she could be heard anxiously calling for her mate – ‘get yourself back here you lazy blighter, I want to go out’. Half an hour of such pleading and he would roost in the Walnut tree and plead his case from 50 yards away to do whatever he did all day a mite longer. Eventually he would drag himself reluctantly home and they would perform gymnastics worthy of the cirque du soleil. Her foot out, his foot in, shuffle, shuffle, his other foot in, that feeble branch threatening to snap in two under their combined weight; finally she was free of her duty and could go out with the girls. We never did see her come home, it must have been after dark, but she was always there in the morning.
I set myself goals; ‘I was going to see the egg hatch’, then it was ‘I’m going to see the chick fly’. A progress report was always first on the agenda when I returned from hospital visits, long before I checked the computer.
In time, the egg did hatch, though we could see nothing – we knew by the fact that Mr Dove was pressed into duty – that chick could eat; hour after a hour both parents provided a conveyor belt of half digested food, and eventually we could see a tiny beak pecking greedily at their crop. Now the parents had to balance precariously on the branch, one at a time; another ample form was weighing it down – some chick! It overflowed the nest as Mrs Dove had once done.
The chick cautiously balanced first one foot, then the other, on the side of the nest. For several days it walked round the edge of the nest, always yelling for more food, but never venturing further. Until the day came when both parents resolutely remained in the walnut tree; the call changed – now it was ‘if you’re hungry, come and get it’. A minor tantrum ensued. ‘Shan’t’, ‘won’t’. Mr and Mrs Dove held their ground; we watched spell bound.
The chick flapped its wings, and plummeted rather than flew, to another branch three foot or so below. As it did so, there was a commotion in the Lime tree. A tiding of Magpies live there and they had spied a plump and tasty chick venturing out alone. The parents flew screeching angrily into the flock, trying to chase them away, but they were hopelessly out numbered. As they wheeled and turned in the sky, so, over the line of poplar trees, appeared 20 or so of the village Doves. They have never before appeared in our garden; they must have heard the calls of alarm, and in a concerted action they drove the Magpies back into the Lime trees. Baby Dove was safe!
He learnt to fly, he learnt to scavenge for fruits and seeds, he learnt that the telegraph pole was a handy staging post for the walnut tree; then came the day when all three of them vanished. We were bereft, the view from the kitchen window would never be the same. The leaves fell from the Cotinus tree, and I took to walking in the forest as I got stronger.
One day I ventured into a new part of the forest; a broken sign read ‘Attention’, but attention to what was long since missing. There was a clearing, and round the clearing were signs of humans, a cheese wrapper here, an empty packet of cigarettes there. Then wires leading up into the trees, some 30 foot above. More wires, a foot above the ground. As I looked up into the trees, there were nesting boxes at the end of the wires, again, 30 foot or so up the trees – however had someone managed to put them there? Then nets, carefully rolled up, and a tunnel of bracken with a rickety shed at the end of it. Was somebody living there, so deep in the forest?
Something about the scene was reminiscent of ‘Deliverance’ and I grew nervous; I called the dog back to me. Then another sign, this time intact. ‘Attention Palombiere‘. What on earth was Palombiere? Some variety of wild boar that was about to charge me? An itinerant version of escaped convict, armed with a heavy duty rifle? The dog and I retreated cautiously; homeward and dictionary bound. My dictionary had never heard of Palombiere, it has taken me some time to find out what it means.
This village is famous for a number of things; one in particular is that every year the Canadian geese migrating south use our church as the marker to turn south west, heading for North Africa. It is an amazing sight; sound rather, for you hear them long before they arrive. Each year houses empty and everyone is peering at the sky as the geese arrive from due north in military formation, and as they pass the church spire, so they wheel away to fly south west. It has happened for generations, and can continue for hours.
In medieval times, similar flocks of pigeons would darken the skies. The men of the village would trap one, tie its feet to something akin to a see-saw, and hoist it high in a tree by means of wires fastened to the top of the trees. As the flock appeared, they would tug at the wire from a ‘hide’ causing the pigeon to flap its wings to keep its balance – the approaching flock would think that the pigeon had spied food in the clearing below and was preparing to land – whereupon, the entire flock would land in the clearing, where corn had been placed for them. They needed to feed – for ahead of them was the Pyrenees, which required extra energy in order to gain sufficient height on their path south. As soon as the flock had landed more wires would be tugged from the hide to spring the nets – and enough pigeons would be captured to feed the village for a month. If you are interested – it was a Basque monk who worked out this method of trapping food in the 6th century. I wonder how long he had stared at his potential dinner flying overhead before he thought up the solution?
French culture, so closely aligned with the food and methods of producing it that their ancestors employed, still celebrates the Palombiere, and these days it is closely monitored to ensure that enthusiastic hunters don’t achieve the same result as they did in America, where the original population of 3 to 5 billion pigeons was hunted to extinction by European settlers. What is left of ‘Martha’, the last known specimen of what the Americans called the ‘Passenger Pigeon’ was stuffed and sent to the Smithsonian museum instead of stuffed and eaten…..
Last week, Mrs Dove reappeared. She roosted in the Cotinus tree and inspected her old nest – before pulling it to pieces. She has spent the last few days flying from branch to the ground, retrieving the pieces and building herself a new nest on a more secure branch further into the tree – I shall have to move the garden bench if I am to watch her this year. No sign of Mr Dove, this is obviously women’s work.
Reading of the Palombiere has posed a question to me that I cannot answer – why is it that we still enthusiastically eat pigeon, and it is delicious, yet the idea of eating a dove appals me. They are exactly the same thing. Technically both are Columbidae – so what is the difference? Could it be a relic of the ancient wisdom of our ancestors that believed the dove to have mystical and religious attributes?
- Moor Larkin
May 21, 2014 at 10:07 am -
New conflicts to come in the 21st Century Kultur Wars perhaps……..
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2510017/Wedding-guests-eat-couples-100-white-doves.html- Ho Hum
May 21, 2014 at 11:39 am -
In Korea, they could maybe let the dogs out instead….
- Moor Larkin
May 21, 2014 at 11:44 am -
I recall Paul Schofield scandalising facebook when he posted pix of himself eating guinea-pigs in Peru…..
- Ho Hum
May 21, 2014 at 11:50 am -
I thought Facebook was the advertising scandal of Zuperburger
- Ho Hum
- Moor Larkin
- Ho Hum
- GildasTheMonk
May 21, 2014 at 10:20 am -
Fascinating and beautiful piece. My heart was in my mouth when baby dove was under attack.
I face similar dilemmas. I love steak, but I would regard eating a horse for food as a gross violation of nature.
Odd. Sometimes what is, is just what is.
G the M - Ho Hum
May 21, 2014 at 11:35 am -
If you reckon that I’d eat one of these, you’d better think again
- binao
May 21, 2014 at 12:24 pm -
So doves are cousins to the pair of pigeons living my back garden.
For two years running these lovebirds have stripped my purple sprouting, even when netted. This stuff takes a long time to grow and I like it a lot.
Sight of a friend’s air rifle last week has prompted thoughts of murder.
But eating? I don’t think so. I’m not squeamish, and I’ve prepped quite a few pheasants over the years, but pigeons? No. - Ed P
May 21, 2014 at 12:56 pm -
What a delightful tale!
(The song, “Una Paloma Blanca” gave me a clue about the meaning of Palombiere.)
The geese turning SW above the church is fascinating – I suspect from the air it is a unique landmark visible for miles. Most churches are aligned with the compass points, so I assume the building does not point SW…or does it?
- Fat Steve
May 21, 2014 at 5:10 pm -
Before venturing to Hong Kong Anna be aware that a much prized delicacy is Raccoon (the fruit eating raccoon is the more highly prized) –I have seen on of these handsome clever sentient creatures in a cage on the back of a bicycle being pedalled to a restaurant to be killed no doubt and cooked ‘fresh’ —-though it is the custom to show ones wealth by ordering a dish and taking just one mouthful. I am not sure there is any distinction to be drawn between a pigeon or a dove and I am unclear the justification for one sentient creature to be killed simply to titillate the taste buds of another.
- Engineer
May 21, 2014 at 6:34 pm -
I think we can all quietly give thanks that we live in an age that allows the luxury of being able to choose what we eat. It really isn’t that long ago that people were, from time to time, very glad to eat anything available. Periods of famine have occurred in Britain in previous centuries, in Ireland more recently, and in parts of the world are today’s reality. In those periods, as it is for many other species (such as magpies), eating other sentient creatures is a simple matter of survival.
- Fat Steve
May 21, 2014 at 9:25 pm -
I would not disagree but that was not my point
- Engineer
May 22, 2014 at 9:01 am -
Ask the fox why so much slaughter is justified in the chicken coop when one bird would satisfy it’s hunger.
Our attitudes to nature have been a little skewed by the relative plenty we enjoy, and by the relentless Bambification from Hollywood and elsewhere. Maybe some societies are still rather closer to nature than we in the ‘developed West’. (That’s not to justify the killing of a sentient creature just to titillate the tastebuds of a human with more money than sense, by the way – it’s just an observation.)
- Fat Steve
May 23, 2014 at 7:24 pm -
Oh and Central Hong Kong and its inhabitants aren’t particularly close to nature !!!
- Fat Steve
- Engineer
- Fat Steve
- Engineer
- Engineer
May 21, 2014 at 6:28 pm -
I know it’s a bit prosaic, but it may just be down to size. A dove is not much bigger than a blackbird, so there’s not really that much meat on them. Pigeons (well, wood pigeons, anyway) are about three times the size of a dove – even then, pigeon breasts are significantly smaller than duck breasts.
- Fat Steve
May 21, 2014 at 9:28 pm -
Unless I have misunderstood the question latent in Anna’s blog its the wrapping rather than the size of the portion that raises the question.
- Engineer
May 22, 2014 at 8:55 am -
Perhaps – but if we were hungry enough, we’d eat it irrespective of how cute the packaging.
- Fat Steve
May 23, 2014 at 7:18 pm -
Again Engineer I don’t disagree—when was the last time you or anyone else in the Western world were so hungry—through lack—that they had to eat a sentient creature? Meat is a luxury to the poor not a necessity—-as to Disney? well I don’t eat bambies……… or thumpers for that matter but that is not coz of Disney……but if I didn’t have a choice I am sure I would ……but for the moment I do so I don’t. As to foxes? well humans are meant to have reason as well sentience so I am not sure its a good justification for human behaviour…….and so legend has it foxes are serial killers for fun but I feed a family of foxes and pheasants eat near them at the same time —my point though was that apart from some (by no means advanced civilisations) that eat everything more advanced cultures see a dignity in some creatures that is respected by not looking on them as a source of food.
- Engineer
May 23, 2014 at 8:30 pm -
I do eat venison, and very good it is too (usually). The last time there was serious hunger in the developed West was WW2 – we got off relatively lightly in Britain (just about!), though parts of the Continent were down to eating grass during the latter months of the conflict. It’s also worth noting that the number of Exmoor ponies dropped dramatically during the war years; where they went is ‘unexplained’. My point about foxes stands – ask any hill-farmer during lambing time. Foxes are vermin if their numbers rise high enough.
- Fat Steve
May 24, 2014 at 9:51 am -
I have deer on my land and I derive much pleasure from seeing them —-mind you they come into the garden and eat the trees and the flowers which annoys well infuriates really (yes I am lucky enough to be both close to nature and put Disney on the tele if I wanted) but I prefer to see them alive and happy than think of them as a potential plate of food —-though I can see merit in culling deer for the general good of the countryside though am personally in some difficulties in culling them because their meat is ‘very good’ (which it is coz I have eaten it) —but I am not sniffy about those that eat meat and serve it if I have guests that would consider me a poor host if I didn’t —well they would eat it at home in any event I guess.
I agree about WW2 which came to mind as I posted as I did —Is war the natural state or the end that man should strive towards and consequences are natural? actually I can’t answer other than for myself on that one.
I don’t profess to know a great deal about foxes —-I do know that living as I do in the country I am not the only one that feeds them and sees a dignity in them and derives a pleasure from that perception of them –perhaps no different from mankind they want to survive and do so as best they can in prevailing circumstances but unlike mankind (possessed of greater reason) apply such reason as they possess to nothing other than their survival rather than pleasure for the sake of pleasure at the expense of others — whether of their own species or others. I am not sure whether the serial killer mode is pleasure or confusion since in a natural environment they appear not to be serial killers otherwise my land would be littered with bunny corpses I would have thought.
The debate I think might reasonably centre on what dominion over animals might mean (whether one is religious or not for man’s dominion over animals is an actuality whether God given or not) —and the extent of the rights of such dominion —-and whether there are duties owed and what those duties might be when one has dominion –perhaps it is the outcomes one strives towards if one has dominion and so it is the same with any human who has dominion or wants dominion over another human —rights? and duties? —-and outcomes worked towards —strange how most people think only of rights and yet never seem happy with the extent of them —-always think they might look at duties as a source of fulfilment
- Fat Steve
- Engineer
- Fat Steve
- Engineer
- Fat Steve
- Gloria Smudd
May 22, 2014 at 7:58 am -
You could always indulge Mr G’s love of MotoGP by allowing him to name this year’s squab Dove-izioso? Or even just Andrea!
- GildasTheMonk
May 22, 2014 at 9:28 am -
I have joined campaigns and signed petitions about the utter shame that is Korea’s and indeed much of South Asia’s attitude to and treatment of dogs. Loyal, higher sentient creatures, I find that appalling and sickening.
- Ms Mildred
May 22, 2014 at 10:50 am -
Two Wood Pigeons had mated on our wall a while back. Now they have built a rough nest in the old hawthorn about 15 feet from the kitchen window. We live in town, about 10 minutes oldie walk from the centre. They are beautiful, large clumsy birds. I couldn’t ever eat one. Just as I couldn’t eat a blackbird baked in a pie along with 23 other blackbirds. Our Blackbirds are feeding young too but the Magpie ate them last year, nature is very cruel. Special buildings and ponds enabled people in olden times to eat carp and pigeons as they needed this to get them through the winters. I hope your seminar was of value to you Anna.
- Jonathan
May 23, 2014 at 9:17 am -
Excuse me Ms Raccoon, less of the musical criticism please, if you don’t mind! I’m just a bird in the sky.
- Gloria Smudd
May 23, 2014 at 9:45 pm -
There’s nothing wrong with the music Jonathan. That isn’t what worries me. I just think you need a tiny pre-take-off reminder to take care over those mountains (what with the morning sunlight and all), to ignore the smell of the new mown hay and the vague impression that God is calling and to concentrate on not flying straight for the golden sky light way unless there’s a landing strip you can reach once the sun-blindness wears off.
- Gloria Smudd
{ 29 comments… read them below or add one }