Ethical Compassion
Cheerful Haitians enjoying the fruits of capitalism before the earthquake.
I watch the CNN news from time to time. It’s instructive to see the Americans, if not as they see themselves, at least as they wish to be seen.
The CNN cameramen are legendary, there is no need for medical supplies so extreme that they cannot squeeze themselves into a space better occupied by a pallet of penicillin, and bring the full horrors of suffering non-Americans to your sofa. They have perfected the art of portraying the dying and pitiful – they home in on the widest, most uncomprehending eyes, lure a fly to the lips of an innocent pleading child, capture the spilled blood on the sidewalk perfectly.
Their anchormen disintegrate quietly each day, not enough that you worry for them, but a marginally more rumpled white shirt, a slightly grubby neckerchief so you know that they may sweat politely off screen, a harassed expression, to reflect the fact that they have been there for days on end to bring you the horrors. You are not supposed to concern yourself with whether they took up even more space on the ‘few’ aid planes getting through by bringing food for themselves with them – or do they fight the survivors for available supplies? Occasionally they will tell you of the bottles of ‘their own water’ they donated as they fought their way through to areas that ‘the aid agencies haven’t reached yet’.
They inevitably pan away to shots of towering American warships, photographed from the dockside so they look even more imposing and well, towering. The might of the American people come to sort out another natural disaster, amongst the little brown people. Man-Mountains of US Marines, with that curious walk born of testosterone filled bollocks too tightly encased in surgically applied army fatigues are pictured bringing order to the masses, or terror to the masses, or American capitalism to the masses, depending on whether they are disembarking in Afghanistan, Iraq, or the Bay of Pigs. In charge, in command, handing out bubble-gum to grateful children, the Mother of all Battles to fearsome tyrants, or eternal damnation and a spell in Guantanamo Bay to confused Bolton wanderers who thought that growing a beard and learning five lines of the Koran was the passport to getting laid in perpetuam. It’s all the same to the Marines, they just get on with the job, they don’t flinch.
At least, they don’t flinch when presented with orderly queues of the grateful starving, or disciplined camps of those used to the cycle of famine, or even from camel mounted tribesmen that you can point a rocket launcher at from a safe distance. Dealing with human beings who had relatively full bellies just five days ago, who had just learnt the hard way that the plasma screen TVs they cherished after being saved from that well known fate worse than death – otherwise known as communism – were inedible, and buried underneath their grandmother, which was more than they could say for their grandmother, cannot be relied upon to act in the prescribed CNN manner. They don’t make good television.
In fact it makes for thoroughly disturbing television; the sight of US Marines fleeing in disarray, neither from AK47s, nor even from fearsome microbes unleashed in germ warfare, from ordinary human beings for whom five days wasn’t sufficient time to appreciate Ban Ki-Moon’s admonishment that the starving and the terrified should be patient. Panicking human beings behaving like starving dogs snatching a sausage from outside the butcher’s shop and racing back to their lair to consume it before it was stolen from them. The Marines threw the boxes of aid up in the air, and legged it in unbecoming fashion. Nobody chased them, nobody harmed them, nobody was even interested in them; they were starving, and they wanted to eat, not provide good copy for the watching ethical compassionista.
The particular form of American capitalism given to Haiti has resulted in the wealthy being decently buried in the Grand Cimetière in Port-au-Prince – going rate currently $100, but don’t expect it to stay so low, supply and demand and all that – and that is assuming that you deliver your nearest and dearest yourself in the back of a pick-up truck, or dragged through the streets by night, if you want the services o’ one o’ them capitalist funeral directors, it’ll cost you around $1500 – in a country where the average income was $400 per annum and is currently nil. The poor, if they are lucky, are hauled away to a mass grave.
The particular form of American capitalism given to Haiti has resulted in the wealthy owning hotels within easy distance of the airport, the temporary home for the few search and rescue teams that have managed to climb over the CNN correspondents and find a place on the available transport, and so the American media can report that five Americans were pulled alive from the rubble, and shipped safely home to Denver, without so much as mentioning the 70,000 who haven’t been. 1,739 specialised rescue workers have flown in so far, but they don’t stray far from the airport. Out in the boondocks, it took a week before anyone could be found to search the rubble of the university, the UN said nothing could be done, eventually a Spanish rescue team kindly devoted five minutes to establishing that they were too late, and sped off to find the body of a close friend of President Haiti. There is a pecking order in the survivor business.
The particular form of American capitalism given to Haiti has resulted in the Americans taking ‘control’ – an oxymoron in this context, for sure – of the main airport, to a crescendo of complaints from the NGOs and other hangers on who were supposed to be helping Haiti, and who now wish to get out of there as fast as possible, that the Americans were not getting them out fast enough, and besides, they were giving priority to Americans who wished to scarper.
America was so keen that Haiti should not be seduced by the notion of fair shares for all, that it supported the regime of Papa Doc, Baby Doc, and the Tonton Macoutes, as they busied themselves flooding the country with US agriculture and destroying the peasant economy. Mohamed Al-Fayed, doyenne of Harrods, temple of the capitalist, turned up in Haiti to share in this bonanza, and take his 5% cut of the ‘new economy’ (if you don’t have time to read the full article HERE now, do book-mark it and read it later, riveting stuff) The Fake Sheik of Capitalism.
When the good people of Haiti rose up and rid themselves of Baby Doc, and the £800 million of international aid that he took with him, and looked set under Aristide to put the peasants back into a position where they could be independent again, the US threw their might behind driving him from power. Eventually he was allowed back again, under Clinton, but only on condition that he did as the Americans said. He didn’t ‘jump’ high enough for American tastes, and thus the US imposed an economic embargo that strangled the country.
‘Communism bad, especially on our doorstep’ – starvation is an acceptable price to pay.
Recently, since the unfortunate US-backed Lartortue business, when he and his cronies embraced capitalism a little too fondly, and escaped with $4 billion American dollars clutched to their bosoms, the US has put its faith in the UN and other NGOs. The UN in turn has thrown its weight behind a package of measures designed to make Haiti more comfortable for rich American tourists, and the port more amenable to the cruise ships.
The $40 million plan involved transforming the now quaint town of Milot, home to the Citadelle and Palace of Sans Souci ruin, into a vibrant tourist village, with arts and crafts markets, restaurants and stoned streets. Guests would be ferried past a congested Cap-Haïtien to a bay, then transported by bus past peasant plantations. Once in Milot, they would either hike or horseback to the Citadelle…named a world heritage site in 1982…
Eco-tourism, archaeological exploration and voyeuristic visits to Voodoo rituals are all being touted by Haiti’s struggling boutique tourism industry, as Royal Caribbean plans to bring the world largest cruise ship here, sparking the need for excursions.
Have no fear though, the cruise ships are still managing to dock in Haiti, capitalism thrives far from the prying eyes of the CNN crews. Life ‘must go on’, and the ‘Independence of the Seas ‘ has just unloaded its cargo of well fed Americans to ‘cut loose’ with water-sports and barbecues on a private beach guarded by 12′ high wire fences reinforced with armed guards.
Despite the complaints from the French Foreign Minister that a plane load of medical supplies was refused permission to land, by the US authorities in charge of the airport, a Dutch plane engaged in that essential capitalist international trade of children for adoption, managed to land and take off again with 100 children bound for Holland. Rather than find themselves thwarted by red tape, they arrived complete with a cargo of psychologists, doctors, nurses and immigration officials – to ensure that their precious cargo arrived in good condition. Madonna missed a trick here, not for long I suspect. Fear not celebrities, there are plenty of orphans to go round.
The UN forces have spent their time protecting the rich and turning a blind eye to the death squads who terrorise the poor supporters of Aristide. Little wonder the poor aren’t listening to Ban Ki-Moons admonishments to stay calm now. Nor are they much inclined to behave themselves for the CNN crews.
The ‘liberal left’ in the UK urge the American Red Cross to refuse the £5 million donation from Baby Doc, on the grounds that it is tainted money, and some things are ‘just too dirty to touch’. Strangely, the Haitians don’t see it that way. Ethical compassion is something you can only afford on a full belly.
If I was one of the abandoned poor in Haiti, I should be sorely tempted to bite the hand that fed me, quite literally. Whoever owned it.
Edited to add: Last word goes to Constantly Furious, who has unearthed this gem – the EU has sent condolences to the UN.
Jesus wept.
-
1
January 19, 2010 at 18:45 -
Well – that’s a record rant Ms Raccoon.
Agree with 99% of what you say, as usual, but looking at today and tomorrow, rather than back, the US response seems to be more effective than that of most other countries. And I usually have no time for US colonialism. The only thing that counts right now is getting water, food, medical treatment and other comforts to the locals who have been so poorly served by their administrations over so many years. -
2
January 19, 2010 at 21:42 -
Well I suppose the US could decide that they would just leave the other countries of the world who (I assume from your diatribe above) would be much more fitted than anything emanating from Amerika to take on the role of aid givers to sort things out…..and they’d we’d see an equally outraged rant from you about how the US never does anything to help to vicitms of disater.
Mr Knee meet Mr Jerk.
-
3
January 20, 2010 at 01:35 -
I have spent the last week screaming abuse at the TV as political wannabes visit Haiti, announce how their heart bleeds for the locals, how all the aid will be coming today – sometimes – never & then jet off again. Hilary Clinton who talked about how the US was there for the long term – which sounded horribly like the ‘Liberation’ of Iraq to me, Ban Ki Moon who, after almost week since the disaster advised the Haitians ‘to be patient’ & the top of the pile of uselessness our own Sir Richard Holmes (think thats the right name) Supreme Eunuch in charge of UN Humanitarian Aid who opened a meeting to discuss aid to Haiti with an apology that not all the delegates had been provided with name plates!!! People dying & he’s concerned about name plates – that totally encapsulates what a worthless bag of old twaddle the UN is.
-
4
January 20, 2010 at 02:09 -
Welcome to Caribbean paradise. Labadee has been one of the homes of RCCL for over 20 years but other companies do the same.
People have such a romantacised image of the Caribbean but in reality it is a very dangerous place outside many of the secure tourist areas. Many of the islands are like this.
l could tell you many horror stories that involved not only the gangs but also the police, airport staff, customs (and not forgettig the Governments themselves) during the 20 years l worked in the Caribbean.
Don’t expect much aid to get through to the people … it rarely does. Many people will benefit from the aid being donated but it won’t be where it is supposed to go.
As l say … welcome to paradise.
-
5
January 20, 2010 at 04:52 -
It was sick making watching the journalists squeeze in front of the ‘rescuers’ to ram a mike down the air-hole of a trapped woman, it was nauseating seeing Clinton take up valuable airspace and security but I guess both are needed to show the American public where their money is going and what they are doing to help.
The Americans are getting a very bad press from our media but they are there, they are trying and they are doing something.
The difference is ‘Europe’ will probably spend the same amount of money, but on reviews, conferences, expenses and corruption.
We have developed a special type of inertia that spends millions but resolves nothing. -
6
January 20, 2010 at 07:06 -
“testosterone filled bollocks” a bollok is a round ball on the top of the mast of dutch sailing boat, testes would suffice
-
7
January 20, 2010 at 09:42 -
this is an invasion by the yanks
wonder what’ll happen in Cuba when the time comes……..
-
8
January 20, 2010 at 09:43 -
forgot to say,
still, we’ve got Cadbury’s though eh?……oops erm, not ant more……
-
9
January 20, 2010 at 10:56 -
I think of the Americans as just hopelessly naive and ignorant about other cultures, but generally in these situations a force for good. (Excluding US corporates and bankers, where the opposite applies).
Last night on BBCNews, a UK cameraman traipsed uninvited through shells of Haitian homes, until he at last discovered a woman about to give birth. If somebody ‘real’ nearby hadn’t piled her into a car and driven to a hospital, they would have photographed the birth with full gynaecological detail.
I’m afraid we must accept these are damaged cultures at work all at once. Third World folks who want their aid entitlement NOW. US marines who pile in with aid but don’t know how to handle starving folks who don’t like them. And EU blobs capable only of the expression rather than the action.
I’d shoot any cameraman behaving in the way that BBC jerk did last night.
The Slogger (who is, by the way, a racist now – again – for having pointed out that Asian Tsunami victims behave better than Haitian earthquake victims) xx -
10
January 20, 2010 at 15:43 -
200 years . But no progress.
If I was an US tax payer I would say” build your city on a fault line
expect the the roll of the dice, and you are the staging post of
Charves drugs” -
11
January 20, 2010 at 16:01 -
I have no opinion.
Really I don’t. But I’m sure its just temporary.
-
12
January 20, 2010 at 19:31 -
It is my assumption that the large number of CNN cameramen and accompanying CNN personnel will have paid greatly inflated prices for their seats on these planes. At least enough to cover the cost of another planeload of essential medicines and other supplies.
As I say; it is my assumption.
-
13
January 20, 2010 at 20:48 -
@Joe Bratley: “build your city on a fault line expect the the roll of the dice”
San Andreas, anybody?
{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }