Jungle Drums.
I was always amazed that the French managed to have a Revolution. One of the first things you notice in France is how incredibly disciplined everyone is. Compared to the English, that is.
The children, from a very young age, require only a stern look from a parent, to instantly stop doing ‘whatever’. There are no threats, no entreaties, no promises of dreadful things that might happen – just a look. I used to wonder whether they had been battered into submission at just a few months old.
As teenagers, they dress uniformly and demurely; they appoint ‘designated drivers’ to take a group to a nightclub and return them home, still sober, at ?’o clock. They shepherd their younger brothers and sisters to local events, and turn up for family lunches where they engage in adult conversation.
As adults, they turn into irritating jobsworths, with identical handwriting drummed into them at school, and proceed to follow to the letter their contract of employment. Even if they are called out on strike by their union – they do it efficiently, thoroughly and precisely as asked.
There is a lot of fodder here if you were minded to be disparaging about the French – or to illustrate how preferable the English are with their independently minded teenagers with their variety of clothing, their experiments with alcohol and drugs, their determination to rebel and ‘be different’.
These are wild generalisations of course – there will always be exceptions, but they are in the main true.
Which is why I was amused to hear English media descriptions of the CRS, the Compagnies Républicaines de Sécurité, arrival to carry out the requirement that the ‘Jungle Drums’ be dismantled and the occupants moved to more salubrious surroundings.
Note that I say ‘carry out the requirement’ – not ‘try to move’. The CRS don’t ‘try to’ anything. They ‘do’. They have no other function in life than to quell insurrection. Everybody brought up in France knows that. They don’t investigate crime, nor shepherd football fans to safety; they don’t see old ladies across the road, or console you when your best friend calls you a slag on Facebook.
They crack your head open when you disobey – and because they are French, and brought up in France, they think that you should stand still and obey when they turn up and fix you with that same stare your Mother used. The French do stand still and obey when they turn up – they know that it is no use appealing to obscure committees that they should be excused misbehaviour because their cat was sick or their Mother was unmarried, or that they can throw another half dozen stones at the nice policeman for good measure before melting away into the crowd….
Periodically, even the French can be undisciplined, after a football match for instance, and scuffles break out – just watch as the first CRS van turns up. It’s like magic – they don’t actually have to do anything to restore order, just arrive.
The English media commentators are ‘unsure’ of who started the current violence in Calais – I’m not. It will be the first person who assumed that the CRS are like the border guards at Macedonia who backed off when their fences were broken down; or the Italian police who gave in when the migrants refused their trains to Germany and walked off towards Calais – or the English who say they can’t come in to England, but who relent for an alarming number of ‘special reasons’.
Who started it? The first person who failed to stand to attention and say ‘Yes, Sir’.
The English media really, really don’t understand the CRS. I have heard it said this morning that they employ ‘mindless violence’. There is nothing ‘mindless’ about it. It is highly disciplined, focussed, trained for endlessly, and mightily efficient; it is the equivalent of a human nuclear weapon.
The migrants will end up in their new home. The Jungle ‘drums’ will be cleared. There will be broken bones. The English media will be appalled.
They said no bulldozers, yet they were deployed along with tear gas in the #CalaisJungle. @alextomo‘s full report https://t.co/HLQvvEeX0J
— Jon Snow (@jonsnowC4) February 29, 2016
Yep, whatever it takes.
Then the CRS will get back in their fleet of vans and return to their barracks. The French will give a sigh of relief – they get nervous if the CRS so much as poke their front bumper out of those forbidding high walled barracks.
Apparently the migrants don’t want to move house for fear they might be forced to claim asylum in France…
- Andrew Rosthorn
March 1, 2016 at 10:16 am -
A Bout de Souffle [Breathless] directed by Godard was so shocking when watched in a French cinema because Michel [Belmondo] finds a loaded gun in a stolen car and shoots two CRS ‘motos’ in the opening scenes. You knew he was doomed!
- The Blocked Dwarf
March 1, 2016 at 10:26 am -
Stepped out the hotel just behind the Gobelin (Paris-France-Europe for any Americans reading) early one morning to go find a Cafe, was about to light a cigarette when two CRS came running down the rue. Instantly I put down the cigarette, unlit, backed away into the Hotel doorway a bit -like some ‘Hue & Cried’ searching for the Sanctuary Knocker , hoping with all my nicotine flavoured heart that i hadn’t just contravened a ” défense de fumer” notice on the rue somewhere.
It was the day after the Gay Pride march which had had wall-to-wall CRS ‘escorting’ it…as Willy Garvin might have said ‘ Blimey Princess, a Pansy! Pansies -when they’re nasty , they are really nasty!’ and I expect the CRS men were simply, innocently, jogging to their next assignment of ‘kick the shit outta the drunken homophobic skinhead dossing in a pool of his own ayran piss’. As I look like I should be at an EDL rally (although my varicose veins won’t allow me to wear German paraboots anymore), you will understand my reticence to wave and proffer the nice CRSers a cheery ‘BoNNSure Missewers’.
French armpits were designed to transport baguettes not night sticks.
- Antisthenes
March 1, 2016 at 10:36 am -
A nice funny ending. I too have lived in France gladly no longer especially after doing a stint in Canada and finding out that French Canadians are much more to my liking. True though much of what you say about the French and particularly their youth. How well behaved they are compared to their British counterparts. Still I am back in the UK now and it is not that bad. I feared it would be a lot worse. Although I do miss the French healthcare system as the NHS is so appalling and theirs is so good.
- John Galt
March 1, 2016 at 10:45 am -
The migrants will end up in their new home. The Jungle ‘drums’ will be cleared. There will be broken bones. The English media will be appalled.
As Mr. Burns from The Simpsons would say “Excellent”.
I look forward to the Muslim hoards being given a taste of their own médecin (or is it médecins)
- Span Ows
March 1, 2016 at 8:34 pm -
Indeed! I remember the days when the UK actually had a Police “Force” or two; now a tame and limp ‘Service’.
- Span Ows
- adams
March 1, 2016 at 11:10 am -
All very nice . Visit gatesofvienna.net for more .
- Fat Steve
March 1, 2016 at 11:30 am -
Gosh Anna I struggle a bit to think this piece flows from the pen of that libertarian raccoon I first came across cavorting in the fields of Monbazillac giving a two fingered salute to the ‘Nu Labour Establishment’ with one paw whilst toying with a member of it with the other with a glass of the local sweet white nearby to give refreshment when needed. Life in England takes its toll though as well I know
Actually that is possibly a little unfair of me particularly because such libertarianism as I profess is based on personal restraint which is possibly a very close neighbour of enforcement and I am on board with the notion that permanent Calais residents have rights of liberty that need to be respected and if they are not need protection ultimately by force.
But let me make a comment on your astute observation of French ‘obedience’ which actually I think is possibly more about good manners than necessarily embracing the status quo. The problem with actually simply enforcing the status quo rather than fully embracing it (particularly if it is unjust AND oppressive) is that it tends to lead to guile and deceit to circumvent it when personal wishes require it and scratch only a little deeper and hypocricy can be found. Having been through the mill of private education in England I think you might extrapolate from that microcosm to the macrocosm of France
Be wrong to generalise too much about the French in this respect but I do sense ‘transparency’ is not a highly prized virtue in France- Jeremy Poynton
March 1, 2016 at 11:38 am -
“Be wrong to generalise too much about the French in this respect but I do sense ‘transparency’ is not a highly prized virtue in France”
Whereas we here in the UK? None of the governments of the Western World espouse anything remotely resembling transparency. Do they?
- Fat Steve
March 1, 2016 at 11:54 am -
@Jeremy Poynton Whereas we here in the UK? None of the governments of the Western World espouse anything remotely resembling transparency. Do they?
Its strange and I may well have missed the point (not unknown as regular contributors are well aware ) but I thought Anna’s piece was about French social charachteristics rather than an observation on (competing?) political systems
- Fat Steve
- Jeremy Poynton
- Jeremy Poynton
March 1, 2016 at 11:37 am -
BBC all cock-a-hoop about the dreadful clearing of the camps. Oddly, they don’t mention that all the migrants are entitled to seek asylum in France, so in reality, this is nothing to do with us.
- binao
March 1, 2016 at 12:47 pm -
Some years back, in retirement I did a spell guiding heavy loads around continental roads. In France, whereas the local plod appeared to be on some kind of low key work experience scheme, happy to accept a tip, the CRS were to be avoided, innocent or guilty.
The grim faced CRS motorcyclists had not the slightest interest in any kind of explanation or protestation. They were the law and we were there to listen and obey.
Was Judge Dredd modelled on them?- ivan
March 1, 2016 at 9:00 pm -
Those motorcyclists were not the CRS, they don’t use motorcycles. The Guy’s you encountered were the Gendarmes, almost as bad but another part of the military altogether.
- tomo
March 2, 2016 at 10:52 am -
An there is the answer – The Gendarmerie are part of the Army – something that almost all Brits cannot get their heads around.
- Peter Raite
March 2, 2016 at 5:36 pm -
A few years back Mrs Raite and I went over for the Cat Festival in teh Belgian city of Ypres, although we stayed at St Omer, just over the border in France. On the day before we left Mrs R realsied that she couldn’t find her driving licence (she was borrowing her mother’s car, and I don’t drive), but was convinced we’d be OK. On teh morning of the Festival we headed for the border, and – inevitably – we found ourselves approaching an impromptu Gendarmerie vehicle checkpoint. My blood truly turned to ice as she pulled over, and one of them waved us to stop and then demanded our papers. Mrs R, in broken French, blurted out that she had left her licence at the hotel, and she was very sorry. He sighed, glanced at our passports, and waved us off.
A couple of weeks later, recounting the story to a French friend, his expression changed to one of horror at the first mention of the checkpoint, and he was then utterly stunned when he heard that we had gotten away with it.
- Peter Raite
- tomo
- ivan
- Bandini
March 1, 2016 at 1:21 pm -
I’ve seen several news reports including the BBC refer to ‘Good Chance’ – a theatre-group active in the camp.
To the asylum seeker they “deliver workshops… … in specific performance arts like circus and clowning” & help relieve the boredom by organizing “poetry slams, stand up comedy, acoustic sets, theatre performances, rap battles, film nights and mass chill outs.”I shouldn’t snipe, and I’m sure they mean well, but a workshop in ‘how not to bother the natives’ might be a better idea, starting with basics such as how ‘waving metal bars in the air, pelting people with stones & setting fire to buildings is NOT the way to ingratiate yourself’. But with groups such as ‘No Borders’ sticking their beak in it seems that there are those who’d prefer to see people freezing in a makeshift shack than more comfortably (and humanely) housed in a converted shipping container, albeit one not sitting on the back of a UK-bound lorry.
- Henry Wood
March 1, 2016 at 7:26 pm -
Sheesh! You live and you learn. Even when well over 70 years old there is always something new in the world (or on the Internet!) that can make me shake my head in disbelief and ask for maybe the 10 millionth time in my life, “Where do these people get their crazy ideas?” And your “snipe” is no snipe – just a well-founded observance, “a true appreciation of the situation”, as an old boss of mine used to say.
Thanks for the link. (Unfortunately I am unable to donate to these clowns today as all my spare money this month has just gone to EUReferndum’s cause.)
- windsock
March 1, 2016 at 9:32 pm -
Sounds like “Legs Akimbo”.
- Henry Wood
- Ed P
March 1, 2016 at 1:49 pm -
Once they’re all safely ensconced in the shipping containers, it’ll be much easier to relocate them to anywhere in the world…
- Mudplugger
March 1, 2016 at 1:58 pm -
Watch out, Felixstowe…..
- Valeriekat
March 4, 2016 at 4:09 am -
I really wish you hadn’t said that!
- Valeriekat
- Don Cox
March 1, 2016 at 3:22 pm -
Including the middle of the Atlantic.
- Mudplugger
- Bandini
March 1, 2016 at 1:53 pm -
An article in The Guardian has an accompanying photo showing a placard-waving ‘activist’. The figures may be accurate but won’t do their cause much good, highlighting why some are a little wary:
Population – 3455
Elderly – 13
Women – 169
Children – 445
Men – 2,841
Families – 145http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/01/french-riot-police-teargas-jungle-calais-camp-evictions
- Major Bonkers
March 1, 2016 at 3:47 pm -
2,841 men ÷ 169 women = 17 men for each woman.
- Henry Wood
March 1, 2016 at 7:40 pm -
I’m really surprised that the Guardian chose to print that photo. Perhaps they did not read the figures and considered the headline claim was enough: Population 3,455.
You know, when I think back over a long life and then consider now what we can find out concerning the “truth” of a lot of these matters, I do just honestly wonder how much unadulterated BS I consumed from the MSM before the Internet opened things up to us.
I remember lying in my bunk in many different places all over the World, listening to the BBC World Service as my nightime bedtime story, swallowing wholesale, every single thing they pumped out into the ether. Many, many people totally trusted the BBC in those days. I am still in touch with some of those foreign nationals today, people who like me, trusted the BBC so many years ago. When I converse with them now, usually just via short emails, they find that stories from the BBC concerning their part of the world do not tell the entire truth. Often it is reporting by omission, occasionally it is the BBC reporting using dodgy sources. In most cases the absolute common denominator in all of the “complaints” that we all have between us, is the way that the BBC reflects Islamic and Muslim problems, no matter what the country.
There is something rotten at the heart of the BBC.
- Major Bonkers
- right-writes
March 1, 2016 at 2:51 pm -
Isn’t that the same principle that created the wide boulevards in Paris?
There will never be another chance for revolutionaries to hold the city to ransom through blocking the narrow lanes.
When London burned down, people exercising their property rights caused it to be rebuilt to almost the exact layout as before the fire. When Paris burned through revolution, it was rebuilt from ground zero.
- DtP
March 1, 2016 at 7:16 pm -
Plus acting as a natural fire break too.
I think the Metropolitan Police are getting a bit para-military and I still to balk a bit when bobbies have tasers or guns. I guess the nearest Blighty’s got is that Pikey camp in Basildon a few years back.
- DtP
- Kevin B
March 1, 2016 at 3:04 pm -
Perhaps the message from the French revolution is that the peasants* can be all servile and forelock tipping until they’re not. And when they’re not, watch out.
*All thougu it was actually the middle classes that did the revolting bit while the peasants and sans cullottes cheered them on.
- John Doran
March 1, 2016 at 3:18 pm -
For some illumination on how the French & Russian revolutions were funded & accomplished, though not the American, & much more, I recommend William Guy Carr’s book: Pawns in the Game.
John Doran.
- Dioclese
March 1, 2016 at 4:43 pm -
But if they get asylum in France, doesn’t that give them right of abode with the EU which means they benefit from free movement and can legally cross to the UK – or am I missing something?
If that’s right then the French are being crafty and the ‘migrants’ are being thick…
Either way the only way to stop them is to leave the EU
- Red Admiral
March 1, 2016 at 5:02 pm -
I met the CRS once, many years ago in darkest Metz. Not for long though, as I was setting an Olympic record sprinting in the opposite direction.
- JimS
March 1, 2016 at 5:34 pm -
I thought en grève was a daily headline in France and that revolution was in the blood, unlike the English who just “tut! tut!”.
Interesting that the new ‘jungle’ is made of containers – doors slam, twist-locks engaged, en route to Mother Merkel!
- The Jannie
March 1, 2016 at 5:52 pm -
I remember a nice comparison although I don’t know who made it. “The CRS make the Met’s SPG look like the flopsy bunnies”.
- The Blocked Dwarf
March 1, 2016 at 6:17 pm -
+1
- The Blocked Dwarf
- Bill Sticker
March 1, 2016 at 6:53 pm -
Paris in May and June 2015 was an eye opener, seeing not just the National Police and local Gendarmes, but CRS and the army in full body armour, camouflage rig and loaded for bear wandering around the streets. Yet all around the locals were eating, drinking, talking and carrying on their daily lives like heavily armed assault rifle toting Police, Paramilitaries and French squaddies weren’t there.
It’s a strange sensation having coffee and croissants with an MAS-toting Sûreté National copper almost blending with the wall in his mid grey uniform less than five paces behind you. Weirder still to walk by a CRS unit by the Bastille every morning, watching them behave just like everyone else, eating, drinking, chatting amiably amongst themselves at pavement cafe’s whilst their colleagues in the van kept a look out.
Only a complete pillock would try to cross those guys. The only thing to say when they tell you to move on is “Oui m’sieu.”
- Eccentric
March 1, 2016 at 7:11 pm -
Also conveniently missing from our bent mainstream dominant narrative/’Imposed Drivel’.
Is that a VAST majority of c. million displaced migrants (caused first by UK/US mid East meddling & mass murder also of innocent children) are intelligently fast bound farther north to be bravely accommodated by modern EU leaders Deutschland, and other caring Nordics.
While a small mislead minority crammed into Calais are just a UK political & media exploited remnant of the many who have long since found other points of easier entry into reluctant Britain – for the few that want it.
Meanwhile bring back the sanity of Sangatte ?
- Michael
March 1, 2016 at 11:42 pm -
Do they hire themselves out? Weddings, funerals, bar mitzvahs, that kind of thing?
We’ve had recent problems here with Nazi scumbags and equally unpleasant Anti-Nazi scumbags chucking rocks at each other (and the police), not to mention spraying swastikas on St. Georges Hall. If they were up for “doing a foreigner” (literally) I’m sure we could make a contribution to their retirement fund.
- Fred Karno
March 2, 2016 at 2:32 am -
Various cynics have noted that it’s only since the Brexit referendum was announced that the French started acting decisively. allowing Mr Cameron to point to Calais as an example of Britain’s increasingly secure borders. I personally doubt Mr Cameron has that much subtlety – any thoughts, anyone?
- Sackerson
April 10, 2016 at 10:44 am -
Yes.
- Sackerson
- Robert Edwards
March 2, 2016 at 9:31 am -
I saw the CRS in action in Paris during the riots in Paris in 1968. Blimey; they might as well have been the Foreign Legion on speed…
I was only 15, so naturally thought their behaviour q. cool.
{ 56 comments… read them below or add one }