Halal or Hypocrisy?
Living here in the Dordogne, it is difficult to avoid Foie Gras. It turns up in the most unlikely places – stuffed into a joint of roast Reindeer is one I particularly remember….
I don’t have any moral objection to Fois Gras, and am constantly annoyed by the lentil munching ex-pats who stand outside our local supermarket on a Saturday morning in their hand knitted Peruvian sweaters and ecologically correct ‘recycled tyre’ sandals, plaintively asking for signatures on their latest petition against the production of Foie Gras in this, their host country. If it is not the Foie Gras they are objecting to, it is the excellent Veal. The Veal I eat and enjoy, Foie Gras I just don’t happen to like.
It is difficult for English people to understand the depth of knowledge that the French display in their food. It is not food to them, it is a religion. Although the average ‘income’ of each household is around €12,000 you will still find bottles of wine in the local ‘corner shop’ selling for upwards of €50 – perhaps only bought once a year, but once a year there will be a special meal that demands a special wine, and they will dig deep in their pocket to pay for it.
If you go for dinner in a French household where the tradition is that other guests bring food or wine, then you can be sure that someone will have brought Foie Gras that has been home cooked mi-cuit, and there will follow an earnest discussion as to exactly the method which was used, which alcohol it was marinaded in first, how many verses of the Marseillaise the cook sang as she timed it to the precise second….with so much care going into the cooking, you can be sure that any suggestion that the Goose which gave its liver for this feast had been treated with anything other than total reverence during its life time, would have the French cooks recoiling in horror.
Yet the myth continues that because there are such things as Foie Gras farms, where local farmers earn their living producing more than one of these prize delicacies at a time, you can equate the production methods with something approximating the Turkey Twizzler factories of Olde Englande – a land where it is assumed that so long as the plastic packaging says Turkey, you can guzzle it down and believe that all Turkeys are equal…
Other immigrants to this land of fine cuisine are more discriminating, particularly those who adhere to the Muslim faith. Muslims are taught through the Qu’ran that all animals should be treated with respect, mercy and kindness and well cared for. You might imagine therefore, that the dastardly Foie Gras, favoured target for the animal rights activists, might be on the list of Haram or forbidden foods. Not so!
Sales of halal foie gras have increased ten-fold in the last two years, delighting supermarket chains across France.
According to Antoine Sfeir, the Lebanese-born founder of the newspaper, Cahiers de l’Orient, the reason behind the boom in halal French delicacies is easy to explain: “First generation Muslims were traditionalists while the second generation were too busy working,” he says. “They just didn’t have the means, with seven or eight kids, to buy foie gras.”
Halal foie gras isn’t cheap. It costs more than standard foie gras – about 15 euros – but that’s because each tin has to receive a certificate of authentication from a mosque, stating that the meat conforms to halal practices. But, says Sfeir, the current generation of French Muslims “feel they should make more of an effort to integrate.”
In order for a product to receive that precious certificate stating that it fully conforms to Halal practices, a great deal of research goes into every area of the food production.
If only the English would carry out such research themselves into their food, rather than spend their Saturday mornings demonstrating on the basis of something they ‘have read somewhere’.
Veal Blanquette for dinner tonight, just the thing in this uncharacteristically cold week – we seem to be getting the tail end of the English weather…..
-
1
January 11, 2010 at 13:27 -
I’m having hot blancmange with wholemeal bead and butter.
I ate some strange things as a youth and can’t shake them off. -
2
January 11, 2010 at 13:44 -
Why are the same lentil brigades not outside Halal centres gaining signatures for the barbaric treatment their process requires?
Is it perhaps that there is pecking order to trendy causes and Brown trumps Green?
-
3
January 11, 2010 at 14:01 -
As a man who hunt and shoots animals with the help of my dogs (they do the flushing and retrieving) and then eating what I’ve shot I have no problems with eating anything that walks or crawls as long as it had a natural life as possible, reared humanly and then killed quickly without suffering. Therefore I am not a fan of Halal or Kosher killing as I think the animals suffer for too long before they die and I do not buy or eat any meat killed in this way. As for Foie gras I think the traditional less intensive method is the best way to produce it and I would eat this at a push if I were honoured and presented with a dish prepared by any Frenchman or woman at a meal.
I dislike and take no nonsense of people who decry the slaughter of animals or of my shooting of animals yet happily tuck into a bucket full of chicken nuggets or pork ribs without the slightest hint of irony or thought to the animal that has suffered for their cheap and easy meal. Neither do they object to a nice pub meal of game pie, yet they DO moan about shooting being cruel yet never seeming to equate shooting and game pie as going hand in hand.
Nor am I a supporter of the Veal crates of the EU preferring the Rose Veal of the UK knowing that UK young bulls have been allowed the ‘freedom’ of roaming in a big yard rather than immovable in a crate.
The petition people who want to stop veal crates, yet eat meat, would never dream of eating Rose Veal produced in the UK as they think any eating of a young animal to be cruel and therefore off limits, but by doing so they condemn many hundreds of young bulls to the EU method of Veal production.
I will not buy any Halal or Kosher meat, nor will I buy non UK Veal and like yourself I do not like Foie Gras.
The UK is full of double standards as far as food is concerned. One only has to view Hugh Ferneley-Whittingstals cooking programs to see out of touch urbanites who routinely tuck into battery farmed chicken by the kilo each day, but cannot face the reality of being confronted by a fresh dead chicken then having to gut or prepare the chicken, turning their up nose at the fresh killed chicken saying, ‘I think it’s cruel.’ -
4
January 11, 2010 at 18:25 -
My wife grew up on a farm in the S/W Dordogne, she learnt from a very early age to kill and prepare animals for eating and she loves cooking, the amount of time she spends preparing all sorts of delightful cuisine for us, family, friends and social occasions ( of which there are many ) is frankly remarkable and really is a labour of love, we have never had a complaint from anybody, what ever nationality about the cuisine in our household, in fact along with others at social occasions she is often applauded; I will keep a look out for the ex pat lentil munchers at our local market just to express my right to free speech., especially as I LIKE Foie Gras.
-
6
January 11, 2010 at 23:37 -
Foie Gras is a superb delicacy, but my favourite is veal kidneys with mountain mushrooms and onion all fried in butter as done around Lyon, accompanied by a bottle of a decent local French red wine. A meal like that shows up how pathetic the “English” kitchen is by comparison, and what philistines are the English majority when it comes to cuisine.
-
7
January 12, 2010 at 00:26 -
On my 20th birthday I was taken to a restaurant called Le Moulin de Mougin, just north of Juan Les Pins, and enjoyed the best of many first-class suppers I have ever had: 16 courses, all delicious, all eaten with relish by me, my parents, various siblings and their chums (except my younger brother, who did not fancy eating anything translated as ‘pigeon’).
No Foie Gras to be seen but the most delicious thing I have ever eaten turned out to be (as I was told 2 days later) to be pan-fried calf brain. Texture of marshmallow, flavour worthy of the Gods.
What can I say? Would I have eaten it if my French had been better and I’d identified it as such on the menu? As it happens, I wouldn’t, being then v. weepy generally about anything with long eye-lashes being killed and only 2 years away from becoming a shouty vegetarian for the next 12 years. But… it is still the most delicious and miraculous thing I have ever eaten in my life.
-
8
January 12, 2010 at 01:33 -
For those who appreciate good French cooking and are not adverse to getting their hands dirty in the kitchen will find Mastering the Art of French Cooking by Simone Beck, Louisette Bertholle and Julia Child a good introduction to the subject. Like all good cookbooks it starts with the art of the soup and the sauce.
Easily available in pdf format around the internet, for the die hards original printed books can be found on Abe Books and similar.
Enjoy.
{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }